Layering actives

I went to Japan for the skincare. My skin had other plans.

I'd been waiting for this trip for years. Part of it was the food and the culture. But if I'm honest, a big part of it was the skincare.

You've probably heard of “glass skin”: smooth, bright and almost see-through. Japan is where it's meant to come from. It's home to serums that fade sunspots, cult eye creams, and pharmacy aisles that feel like a museum. I'd seen the reviews and saved the Instagram videos and by the time I landed, I had my “must buy” list.

I came home with four products:

  • Melano CC Vitamin C Essence, the little yellow tube that thousands of five-star reviews credit with fading sunspots
  • Haru Japan's Capsule Serum Vitamin C, full of bright yellow capsules that burst when they touch your skin
  • Sana Nameraka Honpo Isoflavone Wrinkle Eye Cream, Japan's best-selling soy milk skincare range
  • POLA Wrinkle Shot Medical Serum, which came with fifteen years of research behind it and a price tag to match

I lined them up on my bathroom bench and started that night.

By the next morning, my skin had broken out.

I was gutted. These are some of the most loved products in Japan. So what went wrong?

Reading the labels properly

When I finally sat down and read the packaging, rather than the reviews, it was obvious. In one night I'd put on my skin:

  • Two different vitamin C serums, one of them pure vitamin C
  • A retinol
  • Niacinamide
  • A completely new anti-wrinkle ingredient, along with a mix of plant extracts

Every one of those might be fine on its own. All of them together, on the same night, on skin that had never tried any of them, was a lot to ask.

I asked the one person I knew would give me a straight answer

I asked Dr Sharad Paul, the skin scientist behind NOTOXMD, to explain what had happened.

“The problem isn't necessarily that these ingredients are incompatible, but that the skin can become overwhelmed when several powerful active ingredients are introduced simultaneously. Retinol accelerates skin cell turnover, while some forms of vitamin C, particularly acidic formulations, and exfoliating acids can increase irritation. Combining these can disrupt the skin's protective barrier, leading to redness, burning, dryness or peeling. Reactions may appear overnight because irritation develops over several hours, especially when products are left on the skin. Importantly, this is usually irritation rather than a true allergy. More ingredients don't necessarily mean better results; sometimes you're simply giving your skin more than it can tolerate.”

And often we are influenced by marketing tactics, such as ‘#1 best seller’, or TikTok top product, however when it comes to choosing your skincare you should do your research into the ingredients and formulation before purchasing purely because of the fact it has been featured somewhere or comes with a “best seller” sign. Dr Paul said:

“A bestseller tells you what's popular, not what's appropriate for your skin. Skin is biologically individualistic i.e., genetics, age, pigmentation, barrier function and sensitivity all influence how we respond to ingredients. A product that transforms one person's skin may cause irritation or breakouts in another. Marketing claims such as ‘No. 1’ often reflect sales rankings or consumer preferences rather than clinical evidence of suitability. I always remind people that skincare isn't a popularity contest. The best product is the one that works for you on your skin, not the one that sells the most.”

However, us girlies are always going to want to try the next best thing, so I asked Dr Paul what his advice is for introducing new products or actives safely:

“My advice is to introduce one new active ingredient or formulation at a time, ideally allowing a week or two before adding another. This makes it easier to identify what's causing a reaction. For potentially irritating products, start with a small amount and use them just two or three times a week, increasing gradually as your skin tolerates them. You can also test a small area of skin before applying a product more widely, although a negative test doesn't guarantee you won't react later. Read ingredient lists carefully particularly for retinoids, exfoliating acids such as glycolic or salicylic acid, fragrances and essential oils, which can cause problems in susceptible individuals. If your skin stings, burns or becomes persistently red, don't assume the product is ‘working’. That's often your skin telling you its barrier is under stress. Good skincare should improve skin health, not constantly challenge it”

What I keep coming back to

My skin is on the sensitive side. It's not dramatic, but it notices things and it can get cross. However, in all my time using NOTOXMD, it has never reacted like this.

That's not luck. It's the reason the brand exists. Dr Paul built these formulas to work with skin, not against it.

So, should you try new skincare when you travel?

Yes. Discovering something new on the other side of the world is half the fun. Just go in knowing what you're getting:

  • Read the ingredient list, not only the claims on the front of the box.
  • Know which actives you're using, like vitamin C, retinol and acids, and don't double up without meaning to.
  • Introduce one product at a time, a week or two apart. If something goes wrong, you'll know which one caused it.
  • Patch test first, especially with strong actives.

I didn't come home from Japan with glass skin. I came home with a lesson, and I'm glad I learnt it.

As a final message, Dr Paul says: Your skin is a living biological barrier, not a chemistry laboratory. Introducing five new ingredients at once (unless in a single formula and already tested for compatibility and efficacy by the company) isn't sophisticated skincare: it’s an uncontrolled experiment!

This piece first appeared in The Skin Question, NOTOXMD's weekly Substack, on 21 October 2026. Subscribe for one piece a week.